ALAPAAfro-Latino Association for Policy & Advocacy
StoriesPolicy

Where the Education Dollars Go: How NYC’s Bilingual, Restorative Justice, and Special Education Budgets Leave Black and Afro-Latino Students Behind

Black and Latino students are two-thirds of New York City’s public schools, yet they get a fraction of its richest programs. In special education, they are 75% of students with disabilities but received just 24% of $723 million in private tuition payouts.

Graphic reading “Where the dollars go.” beside bars showing Black and Latino students are 75% of New York City public school students with disabilities but received 24% of private special education tuition reimbursements

In New York City Public Schools—the largest school district in the United States—Black and Hispanic/Latino students make up roughly two-thirds of total enrollment (23% Black and 43.2% Hispanic/Latino, according to U.S. News Education data). Yet when municipal education dollars are traced across classrooms, language programs, behavioral interventions, and special education placements, a stark contradiction emerges: the students who represent the overwhelming majority of the system receive a fraction of its most enriching resources, while bearing the brunt of its punitive tracking.

For Afro-Latino students, who sit squarely at the intersection of anti-Black racial bias and linguistic marginalization, the numbers tell a troubling story. Crunching 2025 and 2026 city budget data, academic proficiency reports, and civil rights audits reveals that Black and Latino students in New York City are systematically underserved across three critical pillars: bilingual education, restorative justice, and special education funding.

1. Academic & Opportunity Gaps: The Baseline Reality in NYC Classrooms

Before examining specific program budgets, citywide performance and admissions metrics show just how wide the resource gap remains across New York City’s segregated school system:

  • 24-to-36-Point Proficiency Gaps: According to the 2026 New York City Racial Equity Plan, citywide proficiency among grades 3–8 students in the 2025–2026 school year reached 50.3% in English Language Arts (ELA) and 57% in math. However, ELA and math proficiency among Black and Latino students trailed their white and Asian peers by 24 to 36 percentage points. Even inside the city’s most demographically diverse schools, an October 2026 analysis reported by The Educators Room found that Black and Latinx students lagged 21 points behind in reading and 23 points in math.
  • Exclusion from Elite Academic Tracks: During the 2026 specialized high school admissions cycle—reported by the New York Daily News—Black students received just 3.5% of the 4,023 offers and Hispanic students received 6.5%, even though they comprise nearly 66% of the school system. At Stuyvesant High School, only three Black students out of 777 received offers.

2. Bilingual & Dual-Language Education: Uneven Access and Program Closures

Multilingual learners—students speaking 156 languages—make up 44% of total NYC public school enrollment, according to data reported by Spectrum News NY1. Yet access to high-value Dual Language Bilingual Education (DLBE) programs—which build fluency in both English and a partner language like Spanish or French—is deeply uneven:

  • Closures Outpacing Demand: While the city operates 566 bilingual and dual-language programs across 12 languages, Spectrum News NY1 noted that 62 bilingual programs were closed since June 2022 alongside severe shortages of certified bilingual teachers and limited family outreach.
  • The Afro-Latino Exclusion: In practice, sought-after dual-language immersion seats in gentrifying neighborhoods in Brooklyn and Manhattan are frequently snapped up by affluent white families seeking enrichment for English-dominant children, while Afro-Latino students from Spanish-speaking Caribbean households or West African Francophone families in the Bronx and Central Brooklyn are funneled into under-resourced Transitional Bilingual or English-only tracks—or misclassified into special education.
  • Curricular Erasure: Furthermore, standard Spanish-language curricula rarely reflect Afro-Latin American history, literature, or linguistic diversity, leaving Black Latino students alienated inside the very bilingual spaces meant to affirm their heritage.

3. Restorative Justice Funding: Proven Results, Threatening Budget Cuts

For more than a decade, civil rights advocates fought to replace zero-tolerance suspensions—which disproportionately push Black and Afro-Latino youth into the school-to-prison pipeline—with Restorative Justice (RJ) practices that address conflict through mediation, counseling, and relationship-building.

The data shows that restorative investments work when properly funded, yet municipal budget priorities have consistently left high-need schools shortchanged:

  • Suspensions Drop When Restorative Programs Are Funded: According to data reported by Chalkbeat New York, total NYC public school suspensions fell 8% year-over-year in the first half of the 2025–2026 school year to roughly 9,200, with long-term superintendent suspensions plunging 22%—a drop officials credited directly to restorative practices, counseling, and mental health referrals. Similarly, an evaluation by the Urban Institute found that targeted suspension reforms cut Black students’ suspension rates by 8.8 percentage points and Hispanic students’ rates by 6.3 percentage points in pilot schools.
  • Chronically Underfunded Implementation: Despite spending roughly $97 million between 2015 and 2024 across a system of over 1,600 schools—a figure examined by the Manhattan Institute—advocates with the Restorative Justice Initiative point out that NYC has never baselined the $120 million required to fully staff and train restorative coordinators across 500 high-need schools. Worse, as Chalkbeat New York reported in April 2026, Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s preliminary budget proposed cutting restorative justice and school mental health funding—threatening to reverse hard-won suspension reductions in Black and Latino neighborhoods.

4. Special Education: Over-Segregation and a $1 Billion Tuition Disparity

Nowhere is the misallocation of NYC public education dollars more glaring than in special education, where Black and Latino students are simultaneously over-referred into segregated classrooms and locked out of specialized private-school tuition reimbursements:

  • Over-Representation in Restrictive Settings: In formal comments on the 2026 NYC Preliminary Racial Equity Plan, Advocates for Children of New York documented that Black and Latine students are disproportionately placed in restrictive, non-inclusive special education classes. Moreover, a November 2026 report analyzed by Skyer Law found that 85% of NYC students with disabilities come from low-income families, Black students are heavily over-represented in subjective “emotional disability” classifications, and students with emotional disabilities face a 13.1% suspension rate—nearly seven times the rate of non-disabled peers (1.9%).
  • Over $723 Million Flowing to Wealthy White Families: While Black and Latino children make up 75% of all public school students with disabilities, a May 2026 investigation by Chalkbeat New York revealed that NYC paid out over $723 million in private special education tuition reimbursements (pushing total private tuition and service costs past $1 billion), with nearly 71% of those taxpayer dollars going to white students—who represent just 12.5% of disabled public school students. Black and Latino students received just 24% of those funds because low-income families lack the upfront cash and private legal representation needed to navigate the city’s complex “Carter case” reimbursement process.

Policy Solutions: Reclaiming Public Dollars for Black and Afro-Latino Students

To ensure Black, Latino, and Afro-Latino students actually receive the services their tax dollars fund, organizations like the Afro-Latino Association for Policy & Advocacy (ALAPA) and education justice coalitions are pushing City Hall and the State Legislature for four structural reforms:

  1. Disaggregate Student Data by Race and Ethnicity: Require NYC Public Schools to track and publicly report suspensions, dual-language enrollment, gifted admissions, and special education referrals using multi-select race and ethnicity data—making Afro-Latino students visible rather than hiding disparities inside broad “Hispanic” totals.
  2. Baseline $120 Million for Restorative Justice and School Counselors: Restore and permanently baseline funding for full-time restorative justice coordinators, social workers, and bilingual school psychologists in Title I schools across the Bronx, Central Brooklyn, and Upper Manhattan.
  3. Expand Equitable Dual-Language Access and Bilingual Teacher Pipelines: Reserve priority seats in Dual Language Bilingual Education programs for emergent multilingual learners from low-income Black and Latino households, invest in bilingual teacher-certification scholarships, and embed Afro-Latino history across K–12 curricula.
  4. Overhaul Special Education Funding: Redirect a portion of the $1 billion spent on private special education tuition payouts into high-quality, integrated public school special education programs in Black and Latino districts—and provide free legal and translation navigation for low-income families seeking specialized services.

Dr. Richard Nuñez-Lawrence is the founding Executive Director of the Afro-Latino Association for Policy and Advocacy (ALAPA).

ALAPA, the Afro-Latino Association for Policy & Advocacy, is a New York nonprofit for Afro-Latinos across the Americas and the Caribbean.